Anti-Avoidance Rules: GAAR & Section 75A
Understanding HMRC's powerful tools to combat stamp duty avoidance schemes, including recent Court of Appeal precedent
HMRC has two principal weapons in its arsenal to combat artificial arrangements designed to reduce or avoid Stamp Duty Land Tax: the General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR) and the SDLT-specific Section 75A. Use our stamp duty calculator to determine your legitimate SDLT liability. The Court of Appeal's December 2025 decision in Tower One St George Wharf v HMRC applied s75A to an intra-group scheme, and the Supreme Court will hear the appeal in February 2027. Understanding the difference between legitimate planning and avoidance vs evasion is critical.
What is the General Anti-Abuse Rule (GAAR)?
The GAAR was introduced in Part 5 of the Finance Act 2013. It applies to the taxes listed in section 206, which include income tax, corporation tax, capital gains tax, inheritance tax, Stamp Duty Land Tax and the annual tax on enveloped dwellings. It targets tax arrangements that are abusive, applying a "double reasonableness" test to determine whether a scheme goes beyond legitimate tax planning.
Key Elements of the GAAR
- •Double Reasonableness Test: Arrangements are abusive if they cannot reasonably be regarded as a reasonable course of action
- •GAAR Advisory Panel: Independent panel provides opinions on whether arrangements are reasonable before HMRC can apply the GAAR
- •Counteraction: HMRC can make just and reasonable adjustments to counteract tax advantages from abusive arrangements
- •Penalties: a 60% penalty of the counteracted tax advantage can apply where a GAAR case is defeated. Separate penalties apply for failing to notify a scheme under DOTAS
The GAAR is deliberately drafted broadly to capture arrangements that exploit loopholes or technicalities in ways Parliament never intended. It focuses on the substance of transactions rather than their legal form, examining whether arrangements are commercially realistic or purely contrived for tax purposes.
Section 75A: SDLT-Specific Anti-Avoidance
Section 75A of the Finance Act 2003 is specific to SDLT. Unlike the GAAR, it contains no purpose test and no notice procedure: it applies automatically whenever its three conditions are met.
How Section 75A Works
Section 75A applies where:
- 1.One person (V) disposes of a chargeable interest and another person (P) acquires it, or an interest deriving from it
- 2.A number of transactions, which can include non-land steps and arrangements, are involved in connection with that disposal and acquisition (the "scheme transactions")
- 3.The total SDLT on the scheme transactions is less than the SDLT on a notional direct transfer from V to P
The actual land transactions are then disregarded and SDLT is charged on the notional transaction, using the largest consideration given by any one person, or received by V and people connected with V, for the scheme transactions.
The critical difference from the GAAR is that s75A needs no reference to the GAAR Advisory Panel and no finding of abuse. If the three conditions are met, it applies. Its reach is limited by section 75C, which sets out how particular steps are treated.
The Tower One Precedent
Tower One St George Wharf v HMRC [2025] EWCA Civ 1588
On 10 December 2025 the Court of Appeal dismissed the taxpayer's appeal, holding that s75A applied to an intra-group scheme. The Supreme Court granted permission to appeal on 30 April 2026 and will hear the case on 10 and 11 February 2027.
The Facts
The case concerned a series of transactions inside the Berkeley group, on the advice of PwC, involving the 50-storey residential Tower at St George Wharf in Vauxhall. Group relief was denied under paragraph 2(4A) of Schedule 7 FA 2003, because a main purpose of the arrangements was avoiding corporation tax. HMRC assessed £8m of SDLT, 4% of the £200m market value of the lease, under the connected company rule in s53. The company argued that SDLT should be charged on the much lower consideration actually given, around £1.2m.
The Decision
The Court of Appeal ruled that:
- •The s53 market value rule did not apply, because one of its statutory exceptions was met (the company won this point)
- •s75A did apply, because the SDLT on the scheme transactions was less than the SDLT on a notional direct transfer
- •The overall result was that the appeal was dismissed and HMRC's assessment stood
Tower One shows how s75A works in practice: it is a mechanical comparison of the SDLT actually paid against the SDLT on a notional transaction, not a test of motive. The Supreme Court will consider whether a share transfer was correctly treated as a scheme transaction and whether the notional transaction should qualify for group relief, so the position may change in 2027.
Practical Implications
Corporate groups should work out the SDLT on the notional direct transfer before any multi-step intra-group transfer of land, and check whether group relief is lost under paragraph 2(4A) of Schedule 7 because a main purpose is avoiding any tax. Past arrangements remain open to challenge only within the normal enquiry and assessment time limits.
Avoidance vs Evasion: The Legal Distinction
The distinction between tax avoidance and tax evasion is fundamental to how HMRC and the courts treat stamp duty arrangements. The line is often confused in public discourse but is legally decisive.
Tax avoidance
Arranging your affairs lawfully to minimise the tax you owe. It uses the rules as written. Not a criminal offence, but HMRC may challenge aggressive arrangements through GAAR or section 75A, and the courts may apply the rules against the taxpayer (as in Tower One).
Tax evasion
Deliberately misrepresenting or hiding income, assets or transactions to escape tax that is legally due. A criminal offence, prosecuted for example as fraud under the Fraud Act 2006. Penalties include unlimited fines, asset confiscation, and imprisonment for up to 10 years for fraud.
Common SDLT scenarios that cross into evasion (rather than avoidance):
- Undisclosed cash payments: A buyer pays the seller a side cash sum on top of the contract price to keep the official consideration below an SDLT threshold. This is fraud, not avoidance.
- Misclassifying a residential property as mixed-use without genuine non-residential use, knowing the claim is false. The boundary case here is the mixed-use HMRC challenges, Tretyakov, Hyman, Goodfellow.
- False first-time buyer declarations: Claiming FTB relief when you have previously owned property (including overseas).
- Concealing related party identity to defeat connected-party SDLT rules.
HMRC has dedicated SDLT compliance teams pursuing both. Avoidance is typically dealt with through closure notices, penalties, and the appeals process described in the refund rejections and appeals guide; evasion can result in criminal prosecution by HMRC's Fraud Investigation Service.
DOTAS: Disclosure of Tax Avoidance Schemes
DOTAS (Disclosure of Tax Avoidance Schemes) is the regime under Part 7 of the Finance Act 2004 that requires promoters, and in some cases users, of tax avoidance schemes to notify HMRC. For SDLT it was introduced in 2005 by the Stamp Duty Land Tax Avoidance Schemes (Prescribed Descriptions of Arrangements) Regulations 2005 (SI 2005/1868), amended from 1 November 2012.
SDLT does not use the hallmark tests that apply to income tax. Since the 2012 amendment, any arrangements involving the acquisition of chargeable interests are prescribed, so they must be disclosed where obtaining an SDLT advantage is a main benefit. The exceptions are arrangements excluded by the Schedule to the regulations (broadly, ordinary use of the standard reliefs) and those substantially the same as arrangements first made available before 1 April 2010. Promoters of notifiable schemes receive a scheme reference number from HMRC and must pass it to users.
Failing to disclose a notifiable scheme carries penalties, and the Finance Act 2026 includes further provisions on DOTAS penalties. Crucially, a scheme having a reference number does not indicate HMRC approval. It simply means HMRC is aware of it and can challenge it through GAAR, section 75A, or specific anti-avoidance rules.
DOTAS, the GAAR and section 75A operate together as a layered anti-avoidance framework. Any scheme marketed as producing significant SDLT savings should be approached with extreme caution.
How GAAR and Section 75A Interact
HMRC can use both the GAAR and s75A to challenge the same arrangements, though in practice they typically choose the most effective tool for each case. The key differences influence HMRC's strategy:
GAAR
- ✓Applies to the taxes listed in FA 2013 s206
- ✓Requires double reasonableness test
- ✓Must refer to Advisory Panel
- ✓Higher evidential burden
- ✓60% penalty possible
Section 75A
- ✓SDLT-specific only
- ✓No purpose test: applies when its conditions are met
- ✓No Advisory Panel required
- ✓Applied through the normal enquiry and assessment process
- ✓Standard SDLT penalties apply
For SDLT, s75A is usually the more direct route because it needs no finding of abuse. The GAAR remains available for abusive arrangements, including those involving several taxes, and carries its own 60% penalty.
Buying through a company? The rates are different
Companies pay the 5% surcharge on homes, and a flat 17% above £500,000 unless a relief applies.
Before and After April 2025 Changes
| Measure | Before April 2025 | From April 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Nil-Rate Band | £250,000 | £125,000 |
| Additional Dwelling Surcharge | 5% (raised from 3% on 31 October 2024) | 5% (unchanged in April 2025) |
| Corporate Rate (residential over £500,000) | 17% (raised from 15% on 31 October 2024) | 17% (unchanged in April 2025) |
| Section 75A Scope | Applied by the courts in earlier cases | Applied again in Tower One (Dec 2025); Supreme Court appeal pending |
| GAAR | In force since 2013 | Unchanged |
| Intra-Group Relief | Denied where a main purpose is avoiding tax (Sch 7 para 2(4A)) | Same rule; s75A applied in Tower One |
| Finance Act 2026 | N/A | Prohibits promotion of certain avoidance arrangements (Part 6) |
How HMRC Applies Section 75A
Section 75A has no notice or counteraction procedure of its own. HMRC applies it through the normal SDLT compliance process:
Enquiry or Discovery
HMRC opens an enquiry into the SDLT return, normally within 9 months of the filing date, or later raises a discovery assessment if the time limits allow.
Information Requests
HMRC asks for details of every step in the arrangements, including non-land steps, so it can identify the scheme transactions.
Notional Transaction
HMRC compares the SDLT actually paid with the SDLT on a notional direct transfer from the original owner to the final acquirer. If the notional charge is higher, s75A applies automatically.
Closure Notice or Assessment, and Appeal
HMRC amends the return by closure notice or issues an assessment for the extra SDLT, with interest and any penalties. Taxpayers can appeal to the Tax Tribunal.
Time Limits
There is no special time limit for s75A cases. The normal SDLT limits in paragraph 31 of Schedule 10 FA 2003 apply: 4 years from the effective date, 6 years where the loss of tax was careless, and 20 years where it was deliberate.
Practical Implications for Taxpayers
The way s75A works, confirmed again in Tower One, has several practical consequences for property transactions:
High-Risk Structures
- ✗Circular intra-group transfers without commercial substance
- ✗Sub-sale arrangements designed purely for SDLT efficiency
- ✗Structures built around group relief or other reliefs without commercial substance
- ✗Use of trusts or nominees to fragment ownership artificially
Protective Measures
- ✓Document genuine commercial reasons for transaction structures
- ✓Obtain professional advice before implementing complex arrangements
- ✓Check whether a DOTAS disclosure is required before using any marketed scheme
- ✓Review historical structures for potential exposure to challenge
The Finance Act 2026 added a prohibition on promoting certain tax avoidance arrangements and new promoter action notices (Part 6). Taxpayers should be particularly cautious about "off-the-shelf" schemes marketed as guaranteed SDLT savings, as these are prime targets for HMRC challenge under both s75A and the GAAR.
When to Seek Professional Advice
Given the complexity and serious consequences of anti-avoidance challenges, professional advice is essential in the following situations:
Before Transactions
- • Corporate restructuring involving property
- • Intra-group transfers with external disposal planned
- • Transactions qualifying for reliefs or exemptions
- • High-value purchases over £1 million
After HMRC Contact
- • HMRC enquiry citing s75A
- • GAAR counteraction notice issued
- • Enquiry into SDLT return opened
- • Discovery assessment received
Related Resources
Landmark Stamp Duty Cases
Analysis of key legal precedents shaping SDLT interpretation and enforcement
Avoidance vs Evasion
Understanding the crucial distinction between lawful planning and illegal evasion
DOTAS Disclosure Requirements
Disclosure of Tax Avoidance Schemes obligations for SDLT arrangements
Legal & Compliance Hub
Complete guide to stamp duty legal framework and compliance requirements
Calculate Your Stamp Duty Liability
Use our comprehensive calculator to understand your SDLT obligations and ensure full compliance with current rules
Reviewed by

Julie White
ACAStamp duty specialist since 1999Stamp Duty Land Tax Specialist
ACA and Tax Adviser with a career spanning nearly four decades, specialising in stamp duty planning and advisory work since 1999.
